Grammar Tips: Defining vs. Non-defining Clauses
  • 3-minute read
  • 21st December 2022

Grammar Tips: Defining vs. Non-defining Clauses



What Are Clauses?

At its most basic, a clause is a grammatical unit that contains a subject and a verb. Clauses differ from sentences (which always contain at least one clause but usually contain more) and phrases (which do not have both a subject and a verb). If you feel you need to revise these differences, you can read our blog here.

What Are Defining Clauses?

A defining clause, sometimes called a restrictive clause, gives essential information that defines or identifies the person, place, or thing being referred to. Without this information, we’d struggle to understand the sentence’s meaning.

What Are Non-defining Clauses?

A non-defining clause (non-restrictive clause) provides additional information about someone, somewhere, or something, but this information is unnecessary for the sentence to make sense. If the clause is removed, the sentence would still be grammatically correct, and the meaning wouldn’t change much, although we’d have less detail.

Defining vs. Non-defining Clauses

So, defining clauses contain vital information, and non-defining clauses add non-essential information. Let’s compare the two.

Defining ClauseNon-defining Clause

The man who was wearing a blue suit sat down in front of me. Here, the phrase “who was wearing a blue suit” is essential to differentiate this man from the other men that this sentence implies are present.
The man, who was wearing a blue suit, sat down in front of me. Here, there is only one man, and he is the only one wearing a blue suit, but what he is wearing is not necessary to identify him.

You can read more about this here.

Relative Pronouns

A relative pronoun is a type of pronoun that marks a relative clause. The most common relative pronouns are that, which, when, who, whose, and where. These pronouns change depending on what you’re talking about and whether you are referring to the subject, the object, or the possessive.

 DefiningNon-defining
PersonWho/whom/whoseWho/whom/whose
PlaceWhereWhere
ThingWhich, thatWhich

Non-defining clauses never use that.

Examples:

Defining: The hotel where I stayed overnight had a sauna.
Non-defining: Louisa, whose family is from Italy, is traveling home for the holidays.

We can sometimes omit the relative pronoun (in the cases of who, that, and which) if it is followed by a subject, but we usually can’t after a verb.

Find this useful?

Subscribe to our newsletter and get writing tips from our editors straight to your inbox.

Example:

This is the woman [that] I met while on holiday.
I took a pill, which helped with the pain, and went to bed.

We can’t omit the pronoun “which” because the sentence would sound disjointed.

In Text

You will probably have already noticed that non-defining clauses are separated from the rest of the sentence by commas because they don’t contain essential information.

Stratford-upon-Avon, which is the birthplace of William Shakespeare, is a village in the West Midlands.

Defining clauses don’t need commas.

In Speech

Defining clauses in speech often use that instead of who, so “the people who spoke no English got lost in London” would become “the people that spoke no English got lost in London” in speech. This doesn’t happen for non-defining clauses because they don’t use “that.”

In non-defining clauses, we usually pause before and after the non-defining clause (usually where the commas are). We don’t do this for defining clauses.

Conclusion

So, the key points are:

 DefiningNon-defining
DefinitionProvides vital information necessary to the sentenceAdds information not necessary to the sentence
Relative pronounsWho, whom, whose, where, which, thatWho, whom, whose, where, which
Comma useNo commasCommas
Pronoun omissionCan omit the pronoun if it is followed by a subjectCannot omit the pronoun
PausesNo pauses necessaryPauses around the non-defining clause

Comments (0)

Instant Quote

Instant Quote

Need more help perfecting your writing?

Proofed has the perfect editor!

Instant Quote

Price

You can also upload a document to get an instant quote

Icon of cloud upload

Drag & drop your file

or browse your computer

Browse from your device

Icon of cloud upload

Drop your file here!

Icon of loading status

Your file is being
uploaded!

More Writing Tips?
Trusted by thousands of leading
institutions and businesses

Make sure your writing is the best it can be with our expert English proofreading and editing.