AI tools impact almost every element of business today – including content marketing. The promise of quickly and easily scaling your website content, such as blog posts and marketing copy, is a tempting solution for overworked content development teams.
However, relying on AI tools is not the simple cost-cutting method it may seem. Beneath the relative speed and efficiency of AI is a hidden expense many businesses don’t initially consider: an “AI quality tax.” In this article, we’ll take you through all the ways AI can cost you more time and money in the long run – and how you can avoid it.
When AI tools such as ChatGPT and JasperAI broke onto the scene, they promised instant content, even long-form content, in a matter of seconds. This is especially appealing to businesses with a strong online presence under pressure to consistently publish new, engaging content. In fact, according to one survey, over half of marketers use AI for content ideation.
But just because AI writing tools are fast doesn’t mean the content is ready for publication. When you trade quality business writing for AI volume, it results in unforeseen long-term costs and time-consuming damage control efforts. While these expenses may not show up in your initial budget, they begin to creep in throughout the editorial process. Relying on unedited AI writing or failing to fact-check its content can result in declining customer loyalty and trust – two major factors in buying decisions.
The expenses from publishing low-quality, unedited AI content or content that contains misleading or inaccurate information can compound over time and negatively impact your business. Here are some of the most common areas where extra costs can pop up:
Audience engagement is a significant metric in measuring the success of your content marketing strategy, especially when it comes to your business’s blog posts and social media. AI-generated text typically lacks the elements that make content interesting to readers, such as nuance and originality, which erodes engagement and increases bounce rates over time. When your readers lose interest in your brand, they stop liking, sharing, and commenting on your content, which ultimately results in decreased sales.
If you publish a high volume of AI-generated content in a short amount of time, your website may see an initial spike in traffic. However, this typically won’t last, as search engines have become much better at recognizing low-quality or spam content and prioritizing unique, helpful content. That means AI content might boost your publishing frequency, but it can quickly tank your search engine optimization (SEO) results. Once Google flags your site for unoriginal or thin content, recovery takes months and drains time and resources.
Trust is a major deciding factor for consumers in choosing where they spend their money – and it can be fragile and easily lost. For example, if your business publishes an AI-generated “hallucination” and cites it as a statistical fact, it can do irreparable harm to your reputation, even if you issue a correction later on. Fixing AI content post-publication and spending time rebuilding your damaged credibility can cost you more than you save by using AI writing tools.
Credibility matters in every industry, especially if you want to stand out from the competition. According to one survey, 88% of consumers say authenticity is important when deciding what brands they like and support. Therefore, building trust with your website copy can be just as important as your products or services.
Every hour your team spends fixing and fact-checking AI content after publication is an hour not spent on strategy or innovation. This opportunity cost may be invisible, but it can result in decreased productivity in other areas of your business.
To get a better idea of the true expense of AI tools, you need to break the costs down by metrics and consider the following questions:
To answer these questions and calculate your organization’s true cost per article or per lead, conduct the following simple audit process:
Collect all AI-generated content produced in the last six months, such as blogs, emails, and ad copy. Essentially, this collection serves as the database for your audit and gives you a clear view of how often you use AI tools and where they’re having the biggest impact on your content pipeline. Include both edited and unedited AI-generated content for comparison purposes.
Next, analyze the performance of AI-generated content compared to human-created or human-edited pieces. Examine engagement metrics, such as click-through rates, time on page, bounce rates, and social shares. Also, review AI content SEO rankings and customer or client feedback to identify where AI-only content might be falling short.
Once you identify performance gaps, translate them into financial terms. Estimate how much lost engagement and poor rankings have cost your business. This could include missed conversions, wasted ad spend, or billable hours spent fixing low-quality drafts. Calculate the cost of editing (such as hiring a content editing service) and compare it to the expenses related to publishing low-quality AI content.
Finally, implement a workflow that balances AI efficiency with human supervision. Introduce mandatory AI editing and quality assurance for all generative content, and ensure every piece meets brand standards before publication. Over the next quarter, track metrics again to measure how these new processes improve performance.
Subscribe to Beyond the Margins and get your monthly fix of editorial strategy, workflow tips, and real-world examples from content leaders.
Δ
Do you want to take advantage of what AI tools have to offer without escalating the quality issues associated with AI content? Let Proofed be your managed editorial service so you can focus on scaling content production and growing your business. Our editing team members are experts at refining content of all types, including AI-generated content, and can ensure every piece you publish meets your high standards.
Want to learn more about how we can boost your AI content strategy? Schedule a call with our team today.
Businesses frequently experience hidden expenses, from lost engagement and reduced organic traffic to staff hours spent on revisions or damage control. Even a 10% to 20% drop in conversion rates due to poorly written or inaccurate content can translate into thousands of dollars in lost revenue each quarter.
AI-generated content without human review may appear polished at first glance, but it often misses brand nuance and factual precision, as well as SEO optimization. With editorial supervision of AI content, human editors refine tone, verify data, ensure strategic alignment, and turn raw AI output into content that drives engagement and conversions.
To calculate AI-generated content ROI, start by comparing performance data from AI-only pieces and human-edited ones. Analyze engagement rates, rankings, and conversion metrics, then translate those differences into revenue impact. Subtract the cost of hiring or outsourcing editors from the resulting gains in traffic and sales. Many teams find that even modest improvements in quality and human supervision deliver a strong return.
Search engines prioritize unique, helpful content – areas where unedited AI often falls short. AI models tend to produce repetitive phrasing and generic ideas and may occasionally introduce factual errors, which can trigger ranking penalties over time.
Watch for signals such as declining engagement rates or customer complaints about unclear or inaccurate information. Be aware of prospects disengaging mid-funnel after reading your materials. Other red flags include sudden drops in search visibility, brand tone inconsistencies, or high revision costs post-publication. If your team spends more time explaining or fixing content than creating new material, it’s time to overhaul your AI content strategy.
Want to save time on your content editing?
Let’s talk about the support you need.
We use cookies to give you the best possible experience with Proofed. Some are essential for this site to function; others help us understand how you use the site, so we can improve it. We may also use cookies for targeting purposes.